Dream Corps
English Spanish
Dream Corps

Dream Corps JUSTICE joins coalition in supporting the Effective Assistance of Counsel in the Digital Era Act

February 5, 2021 

The undersigned organizations write in strong support of the bipartisan Effective  Assistance of Counsel in the Digital Era Act (H.R. 546), recently reintroduced in the  House by Congressman Jeffries (D-N.Y.). This bill ensures that email communications  between people in Federal Bureau of Prisons (BOP) custody and their legal teams are  protected with the same privilege as legal visits, letters, and phone calls. This legislation  was reported out of the Judiciary Committee unanimously last Congress and was passed  in the House twice – once as part of a COVID relief bill and later without objection on  the House floor. Both of these actions by the House display the high level of support for  this common-sense, bipartisan reform.  

The principles of justice, fairness, and due process upon which our legal system is built  necessitate confidentiality between the accused and their defense counsel. Attorney client privilege is one of the “oldest . . . privileges for confidential communications” and  has been an important part of the American legal system for hundreds of years.1 This  privilege is critical when clients are in custody, and the form of communication— whether it be in person, by letter, by telephone, or by email – should have no bearing on  that protection. 

Currently, individuals held in BOP facilities are uniformly denied the ability to have privileged communications with their lawyers through TRULINCS, the only email system available to them. In order to use the BOP system, incarcerated individuals must sign a waiver acknowledging that their communications may be monitored.2 Without signing the waiver, they cannot use the email system, cutting off any opportunity to communicate electronically.  

The need for access to privileged email is long overdue, and it is more critical than ever  today. As the COVID pandemic has raged across the country and spread through  detention facilities, BOP has restricted in-person visits, and unmonitored calls and legal  mail are more difficult to use. But incarcerated clients’ need to have access to their  lawyers is undiminished, and in many instances is heightened by the delays and fears  brought on by the pandemic. Email is the safest and most cost-effective means of  communicating. 

The Effective Assistance of Counsel in the Digital Era Act remedies many of these  concerns by striking the right balance between the government’s limited interest in accessing certain email communications with a warrant and the need to properly protect  communications subject to the attorney-client privilege. This legislation will only  require the Department of Justice to change procedures concerning attorney-client  communications and still maintains the ability for United States Attorneys to access  other emails.  

Privileged communication is the cornerstone of attorney-client relationships and  inseparable from the due process rights on which the U.S. legal system is founded. It is  past time for BOP to bring its policies into the 21st century and ensure that electronic  communications between people in custody and their legal teams are protected. We urge  you to move quickly and pass the Effective Assistance of Counsel in the Digital Era Act  (H.R. 546).  

Respectfully submitted, 

American Civil Liberties Union 

Dream Corps 

Fair and Just Prosection 

FAMM 

Federal Public & Community Defenders 

Law Enforcement Action Partnership 

National Action Network 

National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers 

1 Upjohn Co. v. United States, 449 U.S. 383, 389 (1981); see also, e.g., Hunt v. Blackburn, 128 U.S. 464,  470 (1888) (discussing foundational importance of attorney-client privilege); In re Search Warrant Issued  June 13, 2019, 942 F. 3d 159, 167, 172–73 (4th Cir. 2019) (discussing attorney-client privilege as “the oldest  of the privileges” for confidential communications).

2 Federal Bureau of Prisons, Inmate Agreement for Participating in TRULINCS Electronic Messaging  Program, U.S. Department of Justice (June 2010), https://www.bop.gov/policy/forms/BP_A0934.pdf.

Forgot password?

Join Dream Corps TECH for 2 days of culturally relevant panels, forums and lifestyle events that will shift the landscape of tech. Be a part of a legacy cultivating future leaders and entrepreneurs to create a pipeline of diverse talent that will redefine the culture of the tech sector.

Register Now!